Resources & Tips
To ensure all students have equal access to the course materials needed to successfully engage in learning, the College asks faculty to provide accessible course content. There are many accessibility resources online but below is a list that has been reviewed and considered valuable information by the Accessible Media Team. This list will be updated as new materials are discovered.
This information is intended to distribute information regarding accessible classroom and online materials to instructors and departments. Our goal is to further educate everyone on the importance of Universal Design for Learning (UDL). Being proactive, rather than reactive, and incorporating UDL during the creation process of classroom and online materials is more time- and cost-efficient. By doing so, students who receive accommodations through Accessibility Services will receive accessible classroom and online content at the same time as their peers.
Operating Principles for Accessible Electronic Academic Content
If a student reaches out to you for an accommodation, work with you partners at the College to provide the requested accommodations within a reasonable time frame. This will increase the ability for the student to be successful in your classroom.
When you create your syllabus, use accessibility guidelines and best practices to provide an accessible syllabus to your students. Consider including a note on the best way to request an accommodation if needed.
When you include images within your course documents, include an alternative text description (alt text) that accurately describes the image. Adding alt text allows screen readers to describe any images to students. This is especially important for any image that is used to provide further context or information.
Equivalent Does Not Mean Exactly The Same
Often, images are intended to provide a quick summary of a complex idea or data set.
Therefore, the student with visual or print disabilities should be given an equivalent
experience, i.e., a quick summary, rather than all of the visual details of the image.
It cannot be overstated that students with visual or print disabilities will usually
require more time to take tests. Therefore, image descriptions should not add to this
burden with the practice of providing all of the visual details of an image. Since
a student who is using text-to-speech is essentially experiencing the information
in a linear way and cannot scan an image, that initial investigation simply takes
longer. Thus, the information provided should not be a burden.
The description author should consider are three basic questions about each image
in order to give effective and efficient description.
- Why is the image there?
- Who is the intended audience?
- If there is no description what will the viewer miss?
Does the surrounding text provide context or description
The describer is a gatekeeper of information. It is a role that is both powerful and
difficult. The describer must balance all of the visual and linguistic factors, must
select which information is to be presented and how it will be presented within the
[time] constraints.
Microsoft Word and PowerPoint provide a built-in accessibility checker and tutorials on how to use their platforms to create accessible content.
When you select electronic materials for class, it is important that students who use assistive technology can access those materials at the same time as the rest of the class. This allows the students to complete assignments on time and engage in class discussions.
When purchasing electronic information tools (EIT), such as software, learning platforms, digital content, etc., follow the College’s procurement process. This includes submitting a request for accessibility review. If there are accessibility barriers identified, proactively identify an equally effective alternative solution for students who may use assistive technology.
To ensure all students can utilize digital media within your courses, use captions and transcripts when creating any digital media, such as videos.
W3C
According to the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), accessible content is created following the four principles of accessibility:
- Perceivable » Information can't be invisible to all senses
- Operable » The interface cannot require interaction that a user cannot perform.
- Understandable » The content or operation cannot be beyond a user's understanding.
- Robust » As technologies and user agents evolve, the content should remain accessible.
Accessible content is one important aspect of creating an inclusive learning environment. Use the following checklists and tutorials to ensure your electronic materials incoporate the four principles of accessibility.
WebAIM
WebAIM (Web Accessibility In Mind) has provided comprehensive web accessibility solutions since 1999. These years of experience have made WebAIM one of the leading providers of web accessibility expertise internationally. WebAIM is a non-profit service center at Utah State University.
Principles of Accessible Design
Below you will find a list of some key principles of accessible design. Most can be implemented without compromising the overall look and feel of your website.
Alternative text provides a textual alternative to non-text content in web pages. It is especially helpful for people who are blind and rely on a screen reader to have the content of the website read to them.
Headings, lists, and other structural elements provide meaning and structure to web pages. They can also facilitate keyboard navigation within the page.
Data tables need row and column header cells (<th scope="row"> and <th scope="col">) to programmatically associate them with their corresponding data cells (<td>), making it easier for screen reader users to navigate and understand the table.
Every form element (text field, checkbox, dropdown list, etc.) needs a programmatically-associated label. Users must be able to submit the form and recover from errors.
Every link should make sense when read by itself. Screen reader users may choose to read only the links on a web page. Certain phrases like "click here" and "more" must be avoided.
Videos and live audio must have captions and a transcript. With archived audio, a transcription may be enough.
- Ensure accessibility of PDF, Word, PowerPoint, and other non-HTML content.
PDF documents and other non-HTML content must be as accessible as possible. If you cannot make it accessible, consider using HTML instead or, at the very least, provide an accessible alternative. PDF documents should also include a series of tags to make it more accessible. A tagged PDF file looks the same, but it is almost always more accessible to a person using a screen reader.
Each page should provide a method to skip navigation or other elements that repeat on every page. This is usually accomplished by providing a "Skip to Main Content," or "Skip Navigation" link at the top of the page.
Color can enhance comprehension but cannot alone convey meaning. That information may not be available to a person who is color blind and will be unavailable to screen reader users.
Write clearly, use clear fonts, and use headings and lists logically.
Ensure JavaScript event handlers are device independent (e.g., they do not require the use of a mouse).
- Design to standards
Valid HTML and CSS promote accessibility by making code more flexible and robust.
This is just an introduction. To learn more, explore our articles and resources.
Document Types
Word documents are the best way to create and store text that is accessible for all students. Saving your source files will allow for quick and easy updates to content and provide full accessibility if a student is using a screen reader or magnifier. Also keep in mind that students can download other file types as needed in Blackboard by using Ally. (Student instructions are available in the Ally section of this document.)
- WebAIM: Microsoft Word - Creating Accessible Documents
- Using official heading styles, instead of just bolding titles, allows for better readability. This can be done by highlighting the text and clicking on one of the “Styles” on the “Home” tab.
- Images must have alt text included if it is not already described in the text or a caption. Stock photos do not need a description (but should be marked as decorative), only the images that provide learning content to the student.
- Do not insert textboxes. Screen readers cannot “see” that there is text inside.
- Web links should be re-named because the URL may be just a string of letters and numbers that may not make any sense to the reader. However, if the document needs to be printed, leave the URL as is AND type in the description or title.
- Use true column and table settings. Do not use the Tab key to organize items visually.
- Be consistent with fonts and do not choose something too difficult to read. A sans-serif font (at least 12pt) is best for on-line viewing (Ex. Arial or Verdana). Not all students using a screen reader will be visually impaired.
- Do not use formatting as the only means of indicating information. Screen readers, for the most part, will not identify formatting such as bold, underline, font color, italics, etc. Some screen readers may be able to convey this information, but the student must use a tedious and time-consuming way of using the program to access the information.
- Microsoft Word has a built-in Accessibility Checker. It is an excellent resource to assist in identifying and repairing accessibility issues. The Accessibility Checker identifies potential problems in your document, tells you why it is important to fix it, as well as provides you with solutions on how to fix it.
PowerPoint (PPT) is a widely used method for delivering presentations, both in class and online. PPT files can be fully accessible if created properly. Using text copied from a well-prepared Word document can also increase the chances of having an accessible PPT. Keeping a PPT simple can help ensure accessibility as well.
- WebAIM: PowerPoint- Creating accessible documents
- Use the “Slide Layout” pane instead of creating each slide by hand. This is the only way to ensure accessibility.
- Use clear and descriptive titles. Vague wording may make it difficult for a screen reader user to know what information will follow.
- Keep slide information to a minimum (approx. 6 points per slide.)
- “Speakers Notes” added to clarify visual elements can be accessed by a screen reader. However, if the PPT is saved into another document type, such as a PDF, this info will not transfer.
- Keep a high contrast between the background and text colors.
- Using at least a 18pt., sans-serif font is best.
- Reviewing a PPT to make sure all text is accessible can be done by checking the Outline panel. It will show, in plain text format, the text that is on each slide. If text is visible on a slide, but not on the outline, that indicates the text was part of an image. If the text is missing from the outline, it will not read using a screen reader. Enter alt text or type the information directly into the slide.
- Add alt text for any images that convey information. Stock photos do not need a description, only images that provide learning content to the student.
- Web links
- Web links should be re-named because the URL may be just a string of letters and numbers that may not make any sense to the reader.
- However, if the document needs to be printed, leave the URL as is AND type in the description or title.
- PowerPoint has a built-in Accessibility Checker. It is an excellent resource to assist in identifying and repairing accessibility issues. The Accessibility Checker identifies potential problems in your document, tells you why it is important to fix it, as well as provides you with solutions on how to fix it. A panel will open to the right listing the issues found. The issues listed are not automatically fixed and must be done manually.
Portable Document Format (PDF) files are the most common file type that instructors upload to Blackboard. Additionally, when requesting digital versions of textbooks for students with disabilities, most of the textbooks we receive from publishers are saved as PDFs. PDFs are not typically created in Adobe Acrobat; they are usually created in another program and converted to PDF. Most of the PDF files on the web were probably created in Microsoft Word. Of course, the accessibility of the PDF depends on the accessibility of the original document.
- WebAIM: Defining PDF Accessibility
- Starting with a Word document or PowerPoint presentation that is properly prepared (i.e., alt text for images, proper headings, appropriate link text, etc.) increases the chances of an accessible PDF.
- Save the source document for later use when updates or changes are needed.
- IMPORTANT: The file must be exported properly. Do NOT use the “Print to PDF” feature or take a snapshot of the document; it will not likely create an accessible PDF.
- When securing a PDF via password protection, be sure to select the “Enable text access for screen reader devices for the visually impaired” option or consider leaving it unlocked.
- Editing PDFs that you did not create yourself is a bit more difficult. If you can get the original Word document and re-save it as a PDF, it will save you time!
Math Accessibility
Creating accessible math is a complex process and requires specific software. We have the technology to produce this specialized file format and can also provide software, training, and information to instructors.
The accessibility of math content requires the use of MathML (an XML-based language used to describe mathematical notation). MathML is crucial for screen readers because it provides a structured, semantic representation of mathematical expressions, allowing screen readers to interpret and convey the meaning of equations accurately. Without MathML, equations displayed as images or text may be inaccessible to screen readers, as they cannot parse the complex structure and relationships within the equation.
- Use the built-in Blackboard Math Editor, which outputs MathML in assignments, tests, etc.
- Use authoring software that outputs MathML or MathJax (e.g. MathType, Pandoc).
- Make documents available in HTML format as an alternative to PDF.
- Convert existing images to MathML using math text recognition software (e.g. InftyReader, EquatIO). Edit math recognition results in an equation editor that can output MathML or MathJax (e.g. EquatIO, MathType).
- CSCC has licenses for both MathType and Equatio. MathType can only be added to a college-owned device. Equatio can be installed by anyone with a CSCC email address.
- MathType Introductory tutorials (wiris.com)
- Mathkicker.AI- Turn a PDF into a docx with mathml that can then be edited.
MathKicker – Empowering Blind Students, One Equation at a Time! - Equatio Academy - Start your Equatio learning journey today
Other Resources
This list will be updated as new materials are discovered.
Coming soon!
General Accessibility Information
- It is important to keep your original/source files when creating content. Even if the preferred end-format is PDF, having the originals can ensure all students have access to the materials and makes updating content much easier.
- Think outside the box. A combination of high- and low-tech ideas can help create an accessible environment.
- It is important for students with disabilities to have access to course content at the same time as their peers.
- Be aware that setting password protection on your documents could prevent a student from being able to use the document with assistive technology.